tldr - is your action reversible?
yes --> doocracy is for you!
no --> participatory decision making is what you need :)
We have adopted it because we’re excited about the contributions that you will make to our community, and we want to do our best to facilitate them. To us, do-ocracy means that if you’d like to see something happen, you are encouraged to take action with transparency and communication.
Transparency means letting people know what’s happening, in a way that they can get involved if they want, and if not, allows you to proceed knowing they are informed.
Communication means inviting feedback before taking action.
Reversibility - The threshold of taking do-ocratic action is reversibility; that is, only take unilateral action if your action is reversible, and you are happy for others to iterate on or disagree with your decision. Otherwise, wait for feedback and consent.
The threshold of taking do-ocratic action is reversibility; that is, only take unilateral action if your action is reversible, and you are happy for others to iterate on or disagree with your decision. Otherwise, wait for feedback and consent. Examples of reversibility might be rearranging the living room (easily reversible), or buying a kettle for the house that you can return if people decide it’s too expensive. Examples of non-reversibility might be organizing a party, throwing something away, or inviting a new roommate to move into the house.
For things that need input from the community or that are irreversible, we use participatory decision making.
In slack start a channel and use the naming convention "#rv_d... " to convey that this a decision making channel. Use @rv-residents to invite everyone and forget to invite others who might be impacted by the decision
Set the time frame in which you'd like to give everyone a chance to discuss, it helps people to know that no decision will be made in under a week or 2 weeks, so that they don't panic :) things can move fast on slack! Set a reminder using /todo help that reminds you to take a temperature check at the end of that time frame. You can use /poll help to check a sense of how people are feeling after a week of discussion.
Try and reach a conclusion that everyone feels happy with in that time and at the end of it, publish the outcome to #rv_announcements and archive the decision channel!
Set the topic to what it is you are
Find a buddy
Do it anyway! We really value action and for us almost everything is about experimentation. Make sure you communicate what you’re up to, and then go ahead and do it!
What is the issue that needs addressing: ‘Our bins are terrible!’
What do you propose to do about it: ‘I’m going to buy more bins and replace the old ones. It will cost $75 and we’ll have to dispose of the old ones ourselves which I volunteer to do.’
Invite constructive feedback, ‘If there’s anything I haven’t thought about, I’d be happy to hear from you.’
When you plan to take action. ‘I’ll order them on Thursday if I don’t hear from anyone.”
That you welcome help: ‘If anyone wants to help, let’s meet at x time and place!’
Engage with anyone who would like to help.
Get the job done, finish it and leave no trace :)
Check in with people to see if they welcome the change that you have made. If not, be open and prepared to reverse it.
Being a Good Do-ocratic Citizen
Leave no trace:If you take on a task, take on the whole thing, and finish what you start. If it’s going to be a big task (cleaning out the black hole of storage) and you are worried you can’t finish it by yourself, wait until you have a collaborator. Leaving things unfinished increases the chance of negative feedback or request for reversal
Support and incentivise action: it’s vital to provide positive feedback of good deeds as well as constructive negative feedback of actions taken.
Offer to take action yourself if you disagree with something.
Benefits of this approach
Low overhead to getting things done
Less decision-by-committee often leads to more creative solutions
Communicating and exciting people increases their likelihood of celebrating you.
Do-ocracy without communication becomes "Tyranny of the Proactive." It can concentrate power in the form of circumstantial institutional knowledge and alienate potential other doers, creating a reinforcing feedback loop of “doers that do” and others who don’t.
Do-ocracy without reciprocity can also lead to some power imbalances
ways of acknowledging the inevitable imbalance in the do-ocracy
Ways to address/potential solutions
Provide clear communication of what you need from people to facilitate getting help from others (people often want to help but don’t know what to do)
Providing lists of jobs/projects to contribute to should they want to
Do-ocratic Thrashing- when two people are do-ocratically doing and undoing each others’ idea in too short a time frame.
Solution - ensure that any changes are left for a week, then as the dooer, check in with people to see if they like it. Don’t leave it to others to give feedback, be proactive in attempting to genuinely enquire whether your actions have made peoples’ lives better!
Belated Feedback- what to do when feedback comes so late that you have already invested lots of time
Solution - set a timeframe during which feedback is welcome and a specific time when the action will be taken in the absence of feedback e.g. ‘I’m going to put this thing in place in a week, please let me know if you have thoughts. If i hear nothing back I will do-ocratise it!’
Find out what each person’s minimum time frame is - some people only check their emails once a week!
Absence of feedback:sometimes the actionandaccuracy of proactive do-ers is taken for granted. Doers can feel alienated when their contributions are not critically engaged with.
Remaining driven to ‘do’ in the face of critical feedback without constructive action.
Active ‘do-ers’ risk greater and more frequent criticism than those who are more passive.
how to deal with people who don’t ‘do’ but tend to create hurdles to ‘doing’
ask people with strong opinions to be involved?